Friday, December 6, 2024

Political philosophy



POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY IS A REALM THAT COMPRISES FREEDOMS & RIGHTS. 

Here is a quick breakdown of three categories: freedoms, rights & equality. 


FREEDOMS

Personal freedoms: freedom of speech, private property, inheritance, etc.

Social freedoms: religious freedom, freedom of political assembly (generally it means a freedom of association), 

RIGHTS 

The nature of RIGHTS depends on the specific democratic functions they enable and their legal scope.

Click here for in-depth analysis of rights.

What is a right? A right is a rule about what is owed to people or allowed to people.

Natural rights: are "natural" in the sense of "not man-made"; one owns them because one belongs in the HOMO SAPIENS club. 
Natural rights are considered "universal."
They apply to all people and do not depend on the laws of any specific society. We say that they are inherent.

Prima facie rights: at first sight, the right appears applicable, but upon closer scrutiny, we may decide that other considerations outweigh it. 

Example: If you borrow a book from a friend and promise to return it on Monday, your friend has a prima facie right to get it back. However, if your friend suddenly threatens to use that heavy book to harm someone, your obligation to prevent harm overrules their right to get the book back at that moment.

Negative rights: permissions not to do things, or entitlements to be left alone. Another way of looking at it is that negative rights are natural. Lockean proviso of rights: right to freedom, private property and pursuit of happiness.

Example: The right to freedom of speech. This is a negative right because it only requires that the government or others do not stop you from speaking or punish you for your opinions. 

Positive right: an entitlement ("one is entitled to") to a specific service or treatment from others; these are called positive rights. 

Example: welfare rights; free education. 

Attention: Positive rights are rights one consents to others having. One is not born with them. 
So, a main difference between negative and positive rights is that positive rights are not inherent. 

Political rights: these are global rights because they include both positive and negative rights. 1. They protect individuals' freedoms from infringement by governments, social organizations, and other private individuals. Such as protection from discrimination on grounds such as race, gender, sexual orientation, national origin, color, age, political affiliation, ethnicity, religion, and disability. 2. They also include negative rights such as freedom of thought, speech, religion, press, assembly, and movement. 

Right to equal opportunity: a state of fairness in society (in education, employment, or housing) where people are treated similarly, unhampered by artificial barriers, prejudices, or preferences, except when particular distinctions can be explicitly justified.

Example: take a person applying for a job. Her chances should be based solely on her qualifications. 
She should not be discriminated against because of position, connections, religion, sex, ethnicity,  race, age, gender identity, or sexual orientation.

Of course, given the complex nature of rights, they do CLASH.

In the table below, see my "Paradox Point."
Clashing Rights
Conflict ScenarioRight ARight BThe Paradox Point
Hate Speech vs. SafetyFreedom of Expression: The right to voice opinions without state censorship.Right to Non-discrimination / Security: The right to live free from targeted harassment and hostility.Protecting speech can degrade a minority group's security; protecting the group requires censoring speech.
Public Health vs. AutonomyRight to Bodily Autonomy: The freedom to refuse medical interventions (e.g., vaccines or quarantines).Right to Collective Health: The community's right to safety from deadly, contagious pathogens.Forcing medical compliance violates individual liberty; allowing absolute refusal puts the broader public at risk.
Privacy vs. National SecurityRight to Privacy: Freedom from state surveillance and protection of personal data.Right to Life and Security: The government's duty to protect citizens from terrorism or crime.Absolute encryption protects criminal conspiracies; state backdoors destroy innocent citizens' privacy.
Property vs. Human WelfareRight to Private Property: The right to own, use, and restrict access to physical land or resources.Right to Housing / Life: The basic survival needs of unhoused or impoverished communities.Enforcing property laws can result in starvation or exposure; seizing property to help others violates ownership rights.
Attempts to Solve the Paradox
The lesson is that rights cannot coexist absolutely. So, modern jurisprudence relies on frameworks to manage the clash rather than eliminate the paradox:
The Principle of Proportionality: Courts evaluate whether restricting Right A to protect Right B is necessary, suitable, and does not inflict more harm than it prevents.
This is the Supreme Court's position on affirmative action. Why? Affirmative action violates a principle of equality: TREAT EQUALS EQUALLY.
The "Harm Principle": Popularized by philosopher John Stuart Mill, this suggests limiting individual rights should occur only to prevent direct, demonstrable harm to others.
Hierarchies of Rights: Some legal frameworks unofficially or officially rank rights. For instance, the Right to Life almost always trumps the Right to Property.
Ultimately, the paradox reminds us that human rights are dynamic social contracts that require constant negotiation, balancing, and contextual compromise.

BASELINE EQUALITY:  TREAT EQUALS EQUALLY & UNEQUAL UNEQUALLY

E1 the principle of opportunities: we all SHOULD have the same right to opportunities, regardless of our differences (even if one may end with unequal results).

E2 equality of outcomes: people should have approximately the same material wealth and income (THIS IS THE GUIDING PRINCIPLE OF COMMUNISM AND SOCIALISM).

COUNTERS: 

1- Striving for equal outcomes generally backfires, since normalizing the outcomes may require a degree of discrimination between groups to achieve the desired outcome. 

Example: giving jobs, positions, grants, admissions in universities, etc., to people BECAUSE OF REASONS OTHER THAN MERIT. 

2- If I have reasons to believe that my autonomy is being squashed at the expense of someone else, both of us having had the same equality of opportunities, I'd feel that I've been treated unfairly 

Example: Imagine I come up with a grading method that averages the Ds to a general "C" at the expense of the Bs and As. I can defend it on the grounds of general equality. Only that in this case, the principle of general equality violates a principle of fairness.

SO: The ideal situation seems to be to keep them in balance. 

There are ideological slants. Libertarians prefer freedom; socialists prefer equality. Liberals are kind of in the middle (favoring both).

Now, both Libertarianism and socialism have problems. Why? 

The socialist idea of distributing wealth (and the engine of communism) has failed historically.

Yet, there are "social" policies of various degrees, for example, Medicare and Medicaid, TANF, and food stamps, and Plan 8 housing, in the US, or the much-touted programs of Universal Health in Denmark, Sweden, and Norway. 

However, it's a mistake to assume these northern countries are socialist. They are capitalist countries with socialist policies. 

As we will see, socialism requires the social ownership of the means of production. 

All of the above gives rise to what is referred to as THE MODERN POLITICAL PROBLEM

👇




FOR A BRIEF LOOK AT LIBERALISM click here.

No comments: