Friday, September 29, 2017
Wednesday, August 30, 2017
some words of advice (file under philosophy for life)
Hi class. We've had some interesting discussions in class.
Let me state a few assumptions I have defended this week.
Whatever happens in the Universe has a sufficient reason to happen.
I modify this somewhat into: Whatever happens is perfect.
But you recall this "perfect" is not normative (meaning good/bad, right/wrong). I'm not saying what happens is good or bad for the simple reason that the Universe is value/neutral.
Facts are facts. Values are our evaluations of the facts.
_______________
What's next? YOU ARE PERFECT.
What this means is that actually you are a full expression of YOURSELF. Again, no value laden. Only facts about you.
This is good. It allows to look at oneself without any bad faith for dodging one's responsibility into one's own affairs. WE ARE FULL EXPRESSIONS OF WHAT WE ARE.
On the other hand I have this surprise:
YOU ARE A POTENTIAL REALIZATION OF YOUR BEST SELF.
This is beautiful. Now I'm evaluating. I say "potential", this is a future, not the present self. This best self is not just any self. It's a wiser, better, happier self.
But this is not easy. There are so many variations about to unfold of your potential self. BE CAREFUL AND DELIBERATE.
Sophia can definitely help. May she be with you.
Tuesday, July 18, 2017
Topics for exam #2 SUMMER B (miniterm 2018)
3.1
Causal Determinism (C-->E + LN) and Hard determinism (the doctrine that there are no free actions).
Hard determinism assumes that: if CD is true ---> -Fw
As our bodies made up of matter, we must be subjects to the same laws of causation which apply to all matter.
In addition, if HD is true ---> -HR (there's no human responsibility) if we are not free, we cannot be responsible for our actions (since one is responsible if and only if one can make choices).
Soft determinism: Determined actions can nevertheless be free.
1- Traditional Compatibilism (Free actions are 1- caused by one's will and 2- not externally constrained). The reasoning is this:
Principle of alternative possibilities: one can be held responsible for doing something only if one could have done otherwise. "could have done otherwise."
which means "if you had chosen otherwise, then you would have done otherwise."
Think of this example: a student being late for class. He chooses ( A) "having coffee with lots of traffic," instead of (B) "not having coffee and no traffic." For Traditional Compatibilism the student is responsible for being late since "if he had choosen (B) instead of (A), he would have been on time for class.
C/E "Taylor's Ingenious Physiologist. Here the physiologist plants desires in the subject and he acts on these desires. But the desires are not his. This brings the problem that not all of our desires at a given time are necessarily ours.
Taylor is also getting at the fact that there are internal constraints one may not be aware of. Take for example phobias and addictions. These may not be external constraints.
Punishment: How do compatibilists see punishment? Take a look at p. 203. Punishment cannot be retributive (eye-for-an-eye). The only legitimate way of punishment is rehabilitation and deterrence. Criminal actions are dictated by genes and habits (nature and nurture). Retributive punishment makes sense if it's deserved. But according to the Compatibilist nothing people do is really up to them.
Punishment is good as education. It can teach criminals their error and help rehabilitate them.
3.3 Libertarianism
You should know the difference between "event causation" and "agent causation."
synaptic activity is event causation. mental states causing synaptic activity is agent causation.
Libertarianism holds that agents can cause events. How? Well, our actions are under our control because they are caused by ourselves.
Keep in mind that acting freely requires deciding for yourself what desires you're going to act on. If your actions are based on desires that have been programmed into you from without, then you don't act freely.
There are two arguments here:
Argument from Experience. Argument from deliberation. In class I called it argument from experience, because you experience it from the inside. You feel you wanted to come to class, you got ready, drove through rush hour and got to the class on time. You feel you chose that. You are responsible for that action.
Read pages 216 and 217! For the libertarian if the wants you act on are not yours, you are not free and therefore not responsible. If you declared nursing as a major because it's the dream of your parents that doesn't automatically make you free.That may not be your desire. In fact you may not even know what you really want!
Libet's Neurophysiological challenge: it seems to show that consciousness of a decision arises only after the decision has already been made (the 300 millisecond gap between the decision to press the button and the brain signal).
Rebuttal by libertarians: There's a difference between making a "conscious decision" and a "meta-conscious decision" (meta-conscious awareness is second order). For the libertarian, the subject in Libet's report is not having a "conscious" but a "meta-conscious" decision. So it's no surprise that it happens "after" the conscious decision was made.
Tuesday, July 11, 2017
Sunday, July 9, 2017
Final exam, Chapter 5 MINITERM
Ethics is the study of moral norms & values.
Moral norms emerge from non-moral norms. i.e., "incest is wrong" only when brother & sister have sick babies.
Moral norms are behaviors of fundamental consequence for human welfare. They ensure survival.
mj= mn + mf (moral judgments are equivalent of moral norms and moral facts)
Ethics can be broadly divided into objectivism (Formalism, Realism) and subjectivism (Relativism, Consequentialism). Formalism is the view that right and wrong are independent from peoples' beliefs. Relativism is the view that right and wrong are dependent of peoples' beliefs.
Cultural relativism: The doctrine that what makes an action right is that it's approved by that culture.
Counterarguments to cultural relativism here.
What's the structure of moral knowledge? Find it here.
6. Are there universal moral principles? YES. 1- Principle of mercy (Unnecessary suffering is wrong) 2- Principle of justice (Treat equals equally).
Section 5.2
Difference between consequentialist theories and formalist theories. Consequentialism is the theory that judges the rightness or wrongness of an action in terms of its consequences. Formalism is the theory that judges the rightness or wrongness of an action in terms of the action's form (i.e., "killing is wrong": the formalist believes that moral actions are objective).
Intrinsic (value for its own sake; personhood is an essential value: a-reason, b-autonomy, c-sentience, d-freedom) and instrumental values (value for the sake of something else).
Ethical egoism: What makes an action right is that it promotes one's BEST interest. This is equivalent to a calculus of prudence.
Find more arguments for Ethical Egoism here.
Counterargument: Moral agents are mot mere instruments for one's interest.
Act Utilitarianism: What makes an action right is that it maximizes happiness everyone considered.
Counterarguments: (a) McCloskey’s informant (problems with rights) (b) Brandt’s Heir (problems with duties), (c) Goodwin's Fire Rescue (problems with duties), (e) Ewing's Utilitarian torture (problems with justice). Duties: obligations one has by virtue of one's embeddedness in society. Filial, social, etc. Justice: justice is fairness.
Here you have more arguments for traditional utilitarianism.
Section 5.3
Kant’s Categorical Imperative: What makes an action right is that everyone can act on it (which yields universalizability), and you'd have everyone acting on it (which yields reversibility: Golden Rule). Remember Triff's circuit.
Perfect duty: A duty that must always be performed no matter what (keeping our promises). Imperfect duty: A duty that doesn't have to be performed always (taking a shower every day).
Problem with Kant's first formulation: (a) Hare’s Nazi fanatic (I've commented this as the Al Qaeda paradigm). The Al Qaeda jihadist tells you that he's following Kantian ethics. He follows reversibility since he immolates himself with his victims. His actions follow a universalizability principle since (even if he was an infidel) he would wish that all infidels die -including himself.
Can Kant respond to that counter?
Kant's Second Formulation: TREAT PEOPLE AS ENDS, NEVER MERELY AS MEANS TO AN END.
Kant's second formulation yields the principle of respect. Are there problems with the second formulation? Counterargument: This is known as the problems of "exceptions to the rule". Some times we have no choice but to treat people as means to ends. In the book you have Broad's Typhoid Man. In class we discussed a Danish family protecting a family of Jews in their basement and telling the truth (??) to the Gestapo officer looking for Jews to be sent to Concentration Camps. In this case it's clear we're supposed to lie to the Gestapo. Moreover it's our duty to do so.
Sunday, July 2, 2017
draft revisions (glossary of my symbols)
______________________________
C/P: Fix copy and paste ratio, this is a red rflag for plagiarism. Fix it by paraphrasing in your own words the whole paragraph.
FixSent: Fix the sentence, it reads awkwardly.
FdbetAr: Find a better argument. Generally it means the argument is not relevant. Find a new one.
InsuffRsrch: Insufficient research.
?? : Don't get it, "what do you mean," vague, etc.
Hypb: Hyperbolic. Fix the tone of your sentence. Hyperbolic language is a sign of poor research.
TooW: Too wordy, cut, trim, less is more.
Need+W: The draft is short on words. 1,000 words minimum,
WT: Who talks? Proper prefacing, i.e., Same-marriage critics, or Same-marriage activists, never mind the cacophony, what we need is clarity.
Mss1Pt, missing first point, Mss2Pt, missing second point, Mss3Pt, missing third point,
Insffexpl: Insufficient explanation,
Insffinfo: Insufficient information,
ITC: Missing in-text-citation,
OS: The paragraph needs outside source,
Prefproprly: Preface the paragraph properly with either _____ advocate or ______ critic,
Wednesday, June 28, 2017
On the distinction between number and quality when talking about ourselves (for Summer A class)
Because of our discussion yesterday and some of the comments put forward just before the class ended. We talked about how a white person is not qualified to talk for a black person (and viceversa), a man for a woman (and viceversa), a heterosexual for a homosexual (and viceversa), a non-transgender for a transgender and viceversa). At first, these qualifications may seem limiting, indeed overbearing. After all (as Roberto pointed out), even amongst blacks, a black person may say (referring to another black person) "this black person is not qualified to talk for me."
discussion continues here.
Monday, June 26, 2017
Wednesday, June 21, 2017
Thursday, June 15, 2017
watson: the smartest machine ever built!
as part of our conversation about functionalism & AI (see the discussion about hypothesis and the talk about "corpus" around 4:00).
also, read this article, by ray kurzweil.
to proper understand what Watson does you should be proficient in these areas:
natural language processing, which includes
SYNTAX
morphological linguistics,
parsing,
lexical semantics (a promising subfield of the intersection between syntax and semantics)
SEMANTICS
machine translation,
natural language understanding (this is where the name AI comes from)
sentiment analysis (I love this, where the psychology intersects para-logical processes)
disambiguation,
discourse analysis,
Tuesday, June 13, 2017
Prostitution, choice and Kant's second formulation
As I said, even the Ethical Egoist would pause and think: "Doing that to my body may not be a good in the long run" (prudence is a plus for the ethical egoist). You know, the formalist would see the practice as wrong on reversible and universalizable grounds.
Now, the problem is more complicated. Prostitution is global phenomenon:
Cheated out of childhood in Russia.
Sex slaves in Italy.
Child sex workers in Nepal.
Child prostitution in South Africa.
Here is the Wikipedia entry on prostitution in the USA (see that there are different kinds, from brothel, to escort to child prostitution).
As I discussed in class, prostitution is not generally a "choice" but a socially determined malaise, young woman or man may exhibit certain behaviors and happen to be in the wrong place at the wrong time:
* About 80% of women in prostitution have been the victim of a rape. It's hard to talk about this because... the experience of prostitution is just like rape. Prostitutes are raped, on the average, eight to ten times per year. They are the most raped class of women in the history of our planet (Susan Kay Hunter and K.C. Reed, July, 1990 "Taking the side of bought and sold rape," speech at National Coalition against Sexual Assault, Washington, D.C. ).
* Other studies report 68% to 70% of women in prostitution being raped (M Silbert, "Compounding factors in the rape of street prostitutes," in A.W. Burgess, ed., Rape and Sexual Assault II, Garland Publishing, 1988; Melissa Farley and Howard Barkan, "Prostitution, Violence, and Post-traumatic Stress Disorder," 1998, Women & Health.
* Prostitution is an act of violence against women which is intrinsically traumatizing. In a study of 475 people in prostitution (including women, men, and the transgendered) from five countries (South Africa, Thailand, Turkey, USA, and Zambia):
62% reported having been raped in prostitution.
73% reported having experienced physical assault in prostitution.
72% were currently or formerly homeless.
92% stated that they wanted to escape prostitution immediately.
(Melissa Farley, Isin Baral, Merab Kiremire, Ufuk Sezgin, "Prostitution in Five Countries: Violence and Post-traumatic Stress Disorder" (1998) Feminism & Psychology 8 (4): 405-426.
* Many of the health problems of women in prostitution are a direct result of violence. For example, several women had their ribs broken by the police in Istanbul, a woman in San Francisco broke her hips jumping out of a car when a john was attempting to kidnap her. Many women had their teeth knocked out by pimps and johns. (Melissa Farley, unpublished manuscript, 2000). A woman (in another study) said about her health: "I’ve had three broken arms, nose broken twice, [and] I’m partially deaf in one ear….I have a small fragment of a bone floating in my head that gives me migraines. I’ve had a fractured skull. My legs ain’t worth shit no more; my toes have been broken. My feet, bottom of my feet, have been burned; they've been whopped with a hot iron and clothes hanger… the hair on my pussy had been burned off at one time…I have scars. I’ve been cut with a knife, beat with guns, two by fours. There hasn’t been a place on my body that hasn’t been bruised somehow, some way, some big, some small." (Giobbe, E. (1992) Juvenile Prostitution: Profile of Recruitment in Ann W. Burgess (ed.) Child Trauma: Issues & Research.Garland Publishing Inc, New York, page 126).
*The commercial sex industry includes: street prostitution, massage brothels, escort services, out-call services, strip clubs, lap-dancing, phone sex, adult and child pornography, video and internet pornography, and prostitution tourism. Most women who are in prostitution for longer than a few months drift among these various permutations of the commercial sex industry. All prostitution causes harm to women. Whether it is being sold by one’s family to a brothel, or whether it is being sexually abused in one’s family, running away from home, and then being pimped by one’s boyfriend, or whether one is in college and needs to pay for next semester’s tuition and one works at a strip club behind glass where men never actually touch you – all these forms of prostitution hurt the women in it. (Melissa Farley, paper presented at the 11th International Congress on Women’s Health Issues, University of California College of Nursing, San Francisco, 2000).So? Is Kant right or wrong?
Monday, June 12, 2017
lecture on theodicies
natural evil: evil that humans suffer at the hands of nature.
moral evil: the evil that humans suffer at the hands of other humans.
necessary evil: evil that is necessary to prevent a greater evil of promote a greater good.
unnecessary evil: evil that is fortuitous (this is REAL evil).
____________________
The Ontological Defense: Goodness cannot exist without evil. So a world without evil is impossible.
Knowledge Defense: Knowledge of evil is important (even to understand goodness) and it cannot exist unless there’s evil in the world.
C/A: Suppose this is true, then how can one explain the excess of evil? Unnecessary evil is not justified by the knowledge defense.
Free will defense: Evil is necessary for free will. We choose and sometimes we choose evil over good. Defended by: St. Agustin and Alvin Plantinga.
C/A: 1- A being with free will who always chooses good is logically possible. God is such a being. 2- There’s still much more evil in the world that is necessary. Why is unnecessary evil chosen so often? The theist needs to answer this question.
Ideal Humanity Defense: Evil evolves us humans into an ideal humanity.
C/A: There is little evidence that the struggle for survival has improved the human race. One could argue that the advancements we've made in science are not the result of natural evil.Finally, the ideal humanity defense seems to contradict the Christian principle that each human is of infinite value.
Character (or soul) building defense: According to philosopher/theologian John Hicks, evil is not wrong for our own sake.
C/A: It works both ways, suffering can also debase us. If this is true, then fighting evil becomes wrong (you shouldn’t alleviate a person’s suffering because it’s good for her character)
Friday, June 9, 2017
Topics for Exam #1 FALL 2018
1- Necessary and sufficient conditions (think of some examples as we did in the Homeworks):
"X" is nec. for "Y", iff Y cannot exist w/o "X," or if "X" is not present, "Y" will not occur.
"X" is suf. for "Y", iff "X" cannot exist w/o "Y," or if "X" is present then "Y" will happen.
2- Logical impossibility, i.e. if it violates a law of noncontradiction (something cannot both be and not be at the same time), causal impossibility (i.e. if it violates a law of nature).
Example: Levitating is logically possible, but causally impossible. QUESTION: If something is logically impossible, can it be causally possible?
3- Argument A set of premises and a conclusion.
4- Deductive arguments: valid (if the conclusion necessarily follows from the premises); sound (a valid argument with true premises).
REMEMBER: There are valid arguments which are unsound.
5- Inductive arguments: strong (an argument that would establish its conclusion with a high degree of probability if the premises were true), cogent: a strong argument with true premises.
6- IBE (or Inference to the Best Explanation) also known as Hypothetical Induction: Hypothesis, which if true, would provide the BEST EXPLANATION for the evidence.7- Criteria of adequacy: Simplicity, consistency, fruitfulness, conservatism and scope.
8- Thought experiment, counterexample, test implication
9- The difference between conceivability and possibility
10- Fallacies. These are the fallacies I want you to know: Begging the question, Appeal to the person (Ad Hominem), Appeal to Ignorance, Appeal to Authority, Appeal to Tradition, Appeal to Fear, Appeal to the Masses, Hasty Generalization, False Dilemma.
Chapter 7
1- All boxes in 537, 539, 541.
Justification: The reasons why one holds a belief (there are good and bad justifications).
Truth: Truth is a fact.
Suspension of belief. Neither accept nor reject a belief.
Theories of truth:
Correspondence Theory: Truth is a fact (example: "Snow is white.")
Pragmatic Theory: Truth is what best does the job at hand (example: "Dom Perignon is a good champagne.")
Coherence Theory of Truth: Truth is what best coheres with the rest of my knowledge (example: "The theory of evolution is true because it best coheres with the rest of our natural sciences").
When we don't have all the evidence, or when we're dealing with complicated problems, we may use the pragmatic criteria: With history, forensics, matters of opinion and taste we are more likely to deal with truth as pragmatic than as correspondence.
Guess which theories are expressed by these propositions:
a- "2+3 =5",
b- "all triangles have three sides,"
c- "H2O is water,"
d- "Democracy is better than tyranny."
e- "Les Desmoiselles d'Avignon by Picasso is a masterpiece of Cubism."
Section 7.1 & Section 7.2 are summarized here.
Wednesday, June 7, 2017
Topics for Exam #1 (Summer A)
1- Necessary and sufficient conditions (think of some examples as we did in the Homeworks):
"X" is nec. for "Y", iff Y cannot exist w/o "X," or if "X" is not present, "Y" will not occur.
"X" is suf. for "Y", iff "X" cannot exist w/o "Y," or if "X" is present then "Y" will happen.
2- Logical impossibility, i.e. if it violates a law of noncontradiction (something cannot both be and not be at the same time), causal impossibility (i.e. if it violates a law of nature).
Example: Levitating is logically possible, but causally impossible. QUESTION: If something is logically impossible, can it be causally possible?
3- Argument A set of premises and a conclusion.
4- Deductive arguments: valid (if the conclusion necessarily follows from the premises); sound (a valid argument with true premises).
REMEMBER: There are valid arguments which are unsound.
5- Inductive arguments: strong (an argument that would establish its conclusion with a high degree of probability if the premises were true), cogent: a strong argument with true premises.
6- IBE (or Inference to the Best Explanation) also known as Hypothetical Induction: Hypothesis, which if true, would provide the BEST EXPLANATION for the evidence.7- Criteria of adequacy: Simplicity, consistency, fruitfulness, conservatism and scope.
8- Thought experiment, counterexample, test implication
9- The difference between conceivability and possibility
10- Fallacies. These are the fallacies I want you to know: Begging the question, Appeal to the person (Ad Hominem), Appeal to Ignorance, Appeal to Authority, Appeal to Tradition, Appeal to Fear, Appeal to the Masses, Hasty Generalization, False Dilemma.
Chapter 7
1- All boxes in 537, 539, 541.
Justification: The reasons why one holds a belief (there are good and bad justifications).
Truth: Truth is a fact.
Suspension of belief. Neither accept nor reject a belief.
Theories of truth:
Correspondence Theory: Truth is a fact (example: "Snow is white.")
Pragmatic Theory: Truth is what best does the job at hand (example: "Dom Perignon is a good champagne.")
Coherence Theory of Truth: Truth is what best coheres with the rest of my knowledge (example: "The theory of evolution is true because it best coheres with the rest of our natural sciences").
When we don't have all the evidence, or when we're dealing with complicated problems, we may use the pragmatic criteria: With history, forensics, matters of opinion and taste we are more likely to deal with truth as pragmatic than as correspondence.
Guess which theories are expressed by these propositions:
a- "2+3 =5",
b- "all triangles have three sides,"
c- "H2O is water,"
d- "Democracy is better than tyranny."
e- "Les Desmoiselles d'Avignon by Picasso is a masterpiece of Cubism."
Section 7.1 & Section 7.2 are summarized here.
Section 7.3
1- Standard Account of Knowledge: K= JTB / Counterexample: Gettier's Guy in Barcelona.
2- Defeasibility Theory: K = UJTB /Counterexample: Lehrer's demented Mrs. Grabbit.
3- Causal Theory: K = SCTB / Counterexample: Goldman's Fake Barns.
4- Reliability Theory: K = RPTB / Counterexample: Lehrer's Human Thermometer.
5- Virtue Perspectivism: K = AB (apt belief). Also K= AK (animal knowledge) + RK (reflective knowledge
accuracy ---> goal seeking
adroitness--> exhibiting skill
Sosa believes there are two kinds of knowledge: Animal and Reflective. Animal Knowledge is externalist in nature. The animal is not aware of its knowledge. It relies exclusively on its sense (what I call "antennas").
On the other hand, Reflective Knowledge (RK) is internal in nature: It's a second-order knowledge that is acquired by reflecting on the principles and processes that underlie Animal Knowledge (AK, a first order of knowledge).
This is the picture. If you have AK you can know without being aware you know. If you have RK you basically know that you know.
1. in the case of Gettier's Guy in Barcelona, Smith doesn't have AK, nor does he have RK that "Jones owns a Ford" or "Brown is in Barcelona."
2. In the Mrs. Grabbit thought experiment, the librarian has both AK and RK that Tom Grabbit stole the book.
3. In Goldman's Fake Barns thought experiment, Henry has AK that he sees real barns, but he doesn't have RK that he doesn't see fake ones. So, in a sense he doesn't know he knows.
4. In Lehrer's Human Thermometer thought experiment, Mr. Truetemp has AK of the temperature (he has a thermometer attached to his skull), but he doesn't have RK (he doesn't know why he knows).
These answers prove that Virtue Perspectivism is a better theory than the previous ones. It can tell us what the issue is, and what needs to get fixed.
Tuesday, May 16, 2017
Monday, May 15, 2017
summer 2020 chapter 1 (homework 2)
1. Thomas Elder attack on social welfare should not be taken seriously. He is said to have been a degenerate.
2. You will get pregnant if you have sex. Sally had sex once, and now she is pregnant.
3. Your honor, the defendant must be guilty because no one can prove his innocence.
4. Rare taste: you either have taste or you don't.
5. Men are all alike: selfish creatures who spend every weekend glued to a television tube.
6. I am sure that you will agree that we should all work together to increase the profit of this company. Anyone not agreeing with this policy will be fired immediately.
7. Everyone believes that Lander University is improving its academic programs yearly; therefore, I conclude that Lander will be a much higher rated school several years from now.
8. Theodore H. Teabody, the great historian, says that H. Copi's book is the best logic book in the world. I believe him since the word of such a great man shouldn't be disputed.
Deductive or inductive?
deductive inductive
indicator words
|
|
| necessarily | probably/improbably |
| certainly | plausible/implausible |
| absolutely | likely/unlikely |
| definitely | reasonable to conclude |
1. The sum of the interior angles of any triangle is 180°. In triangle #1, angle A is 30°, angle B is 90°. Therefore, angle C is 60°.
2. If I get an A, then I will pass this course. Odds are, I will make a B. So, I probably won't pass this course.
3. The platypus is not a mammal because no mammal lays eggs, and the female platypus does.
4. The last time I ate here, the shrimp dish I ordered was disgusting. It must be the case that this restaurant buys lousy seafood.
5. The sign on the candy machine reads "Out of Order." The candy machine must be broken.
6. All guitar players are musicians, and some guitar players are astronauts. It follows that some musicians are astronauts.
7. Irene likes either coffee or tea in the morning. But she doesn't like tea. Therefore Irene likes coffee in the morning.
8. These mushrooms have a very similar appearance to the ones growing in the garden. The ones in the garden are edible. The conclusion is therefore warranted that these mushrooms are edible.
9. Most birds can fly and a penguin is a bird. So, penguins most probably can fly.
______________
Valid or invalid?
1. If it rained, the streets are wet. The streets are wet, so it must have rained.
2. If Richard Roe is willing to testify then he's innocent. He's not willing to testify therefore he's not innocent.
3. If Bogotá is north of New Orleans and New Orleans is north of Mexico City, then Bogota is north of Mexico City.
Strong or weak?
4. Every day you've lived has been followed by another day in which you've been alive. Therefore, everyday you ever will live will be followed by another day in which you are alive.
5. Nobel prize-winning biologist Herbert Ralls says that chlorinated hydrocarbons in our water supply constitute a major threat to the public health. Since no scientists disagree with him on this point. Accordingly, we conclude that the presence of these chemicals is a threat.
6. Every day you've ever lived has been a day before tomorrow, so, every day you will ever live will be a day before tomorrow.
presocratic philosophy (what's the arche of the universe)
Pythagoras: arche is NUMBER.
Parmenides: is the father of metaphysics and rationalism. His motto is "whatever is is, and what is not cannot be", i.e., REALITY is unchanging. For something to CHANGE it has to not-be, which is a contradiction, because NOTHING cannot exist and out of nothing nothing comes.
Heraclitus: all things in nature are in a state of perpetual flux, connected by logical structure or pattern, which he termed logos.
The Atomists: Leucippus (5th BC) and his pupil Democritus of Abdera (460-370 BC) from Thrace. Atoms: small primary bodies, infinite in number, indivisible and imperishable, qualitatively similar, but distinguished by their shapes. They move eternally through the infinite void, they collide and unite, thus generating objects which differ in accordance with the varieties, in number, size, shape, etc. We are ALL atoms.
Friday, May 12, 2017
Thursday, April 27, 2017
what to do with EROS?
what does this proposition mean? very little if at all --methinks. the proposition comes to us reified & depleted. its normativity in shambles:
here,
here,
here
here,
here,
let's use new words: EROS, Agape, Philia, Storge,
forget about one thing fits-all, that's ludicrous. let's be naturalists here. LOVE is an human emotion: a visceral, conscious reaction to an external stimulus. it serves a purpose, it brings us closer to OTHERness.
only that there are different "love-notes" for different given referents:
my parents and immediate family? they elicit storge. my friends? philia. my girlfriend? eros.
my mentors and role models? agape.
the picture is rich and complex.
now, i want to address EROS (because you're in the middle of it). EROS is lust, boundless desire for the flesh, a raw emotion which Nietzsche calls Bejahung ("life affirming").
If someone penetrated the depths of EROS, it was French poet Charles Baudelaire. in fact, he redefined EROS for fin-de-siècle european culture. here's a little taste from his Flowers of Evil:
Si le viol, le poison, le poignard, l'incendie,
N'ont pas encore brodé de leurs plaisants dessins
Le canevas banal de nos piteux destins,
C'est que notre âme, hélas! n'est pas assez hardie.
(If rape, poison, dagger and fire,
Have still not embroidered their pleasant designs
On the banal canvas of our pitiable destinies,
It's because our soul, alas, is not bold enough!)
Baudelaire goes against the norms of political correctness of his time. This is a force as unbounded & self-destructive akin to the Freudian Todestrieb.
the problem of love is how to bring it under control (particularly these days of self-centered banality, with social media driving the narratives).
the key is not ever to repress EROS (you'll pay dearly if you do that), but to educate it. each one of us deserves to plunge in EROS' turbulent waters, at least once. How do you educate this riptide? By transforming sexual desire into a productive force.
Give yourself time to experiment. Explore relationships and learn the lessons. See how the sex drive can -at times- drain you or, on the other hand, make you sharp and resilient. for sure, you'll make mistakes, you'll break relationships, you'll suffer, but you'll grow.
it's possible to have pleasure and still respect persons. do not trade with persons. be fair with your lovers and be as honest as you can.
don't worry, Aphrodite will protect you.
Wednesday, April 26, 2017
final draft guidelines:
1- Font: Times New Roman p. 12
2- Heading, left hand side:
John Doe,
Final Draft
Phi 2010, Honors, 10am
3- Title, centered, bold,
4- Double-spaced,
5- Indent each new paragraph,
6- "Bibliography" on a separate page, following MLA protocols (with last day of revision for digital sources),
7- No binders, no blank page cover,
8- ALL DRAFTS MUST BE STAPLED,
Tuesday, April 25, 2017
W. D. Ross' pluralistic formalism
What's the form? A moral naturalist would say: the moral "fact" (recall moral facts are given by moral norms accepted by social-moral-selection). Kant doesn't need this. His categorical imperative works from the presumption that we're all inside the Sapiens Club. We all have REASON.
The problem is that Kant never allows for exceptions to the rule. "Breaking a promise" is wrong. Always wrong. This is a problem for a comprehensive moral theory such as Formalism.
A theory must offer viable solutions in the world, and the world is a jungle.
What if I promise A something, but now, if I keep my promise to A, then B's life is in danger? Should I keep the promise? Kant doesn't say. But W.D. Ross, a 20th Century formalist, did. His theory is known as Pluralistic Formalism.
an action is right if it falls under the highest ranked duty in a given situation.
In our previous example, the promise to A is a prima facie duty (a duty at first sight). I must perform this duty unless... well, unless keeping my promise to A endangers the life of B. This second duty (breaking the promise to A) though wrong in NORMAL circumstances, now becomes ACTUALLY right (Ross calls it ACTUAL duty. The duty doesn't say "break your promise." It says, rather, "DON'T ENDANGER THE LIFE OF A PERSON."
Ross recommends a criteria of duties that I have revised:
1. justice (being fair to people)
2. fidelity (keeping one's word, contracts, written & oral),
3. reparation (compensation in kind to others for one's breaking duties in 2.),
4. benevolence (doing good to people),
5. gratitude (making up, compensating what people have done for us),
6. non-maleficence (avoiding wishing or doing evil to people: think of treating people merely as a means to an end),
7. self-improvement (taking care of oneself).
Triff's Hollandaise
(rumors have it that Hollandaise is not really French but Dutch) then, consensus indicate that Hollandaise is incorporated to sauce status when venerable Cuisiner des Roi Pierre La Verenne calls it "mother of all sauces." The truth is that Hollandaise harks back to the genius of Escoffier. He is to French cuisine what Descartes is to French philosophy (Escofier's Hollandaise uses a reduction --me neither).
I learned my Hollandaise via Abdel, a Francophile Lebanese cook I met while cooking at this Greek Diner I've talked to you about on 95 and Broadway in NY. He was a decent chef, escaping the civil war in Lebanon, but too old to take BS from a Greek ignoramus. Abdel left in less than a month and I took his place and changed the Diner into a Dominican/Haitian/Cuban/Greek/ dive (in NY the neighborhood's ethnicity dictates your cuisine). Just when the place was full of patrons, Carmen made my life miserable and I took a TA at Rutgers fleeing from the crisis (this is when sweet the spirit of philosophy appeared for the first time: Triff, it's me, Sophia. I see what you need).
Hollandaise is the story of the evolution in emulsion sauces (i.e, mayonnaise, aïoli, rémoulade, vincent and béarnaise). The old classical Hollandaise almost qualifies as mayonnaise. My version is suited for our self-conscious, fitness-obsessed times: lighter & delicate.
Ingredients:
3 egg yolks, 1 tablespoon water, 1 tablespoon fresh lemon juice, 6-8 ounces of soft unsalted butter, 1 dash cayenne pèpper, salt to taste, pepper to taste.
Directions:
Hollandaise is a temperamental woman, both in beauty and unpredictability. She demands undivided attention and self-confidence. Why? Emulsified butter sauces sense our human fears and break on us -if you let them, that is. Let's start with whisking egg yolks, water, and lemon juice in a saucepan for lemony happiness. If the emulsion breaks it still gives you a pass at redemption. Whisk the broken sauce back into a clean teaspoon of water and you’ll have it back in moments (as they say: it faut avoir foi en soi).
Back to the saucepan: keep whisking tirelessly until the emulsion gets thicker and pale. Now set the pan over moderately low heat and continue to whisk at reasonable speed, reaching all over the bottom and insides of the pan. Careful: at this stage the eggs tend to overcook. Off the burner, but don't stop whisking! Then back to low-to-moderate heat for a few seconds, and then back on. If, by chance, the eggs seem to congeal too fast, set the pan in the bowl of cold water to cool the bottom, then back on whisking. Now the eggs become frothy and increase in volume, and then thicken. When you can see the pan bottom through the streaks of the whisk and the eggs are thick and smooth, remove from the heat.
Now comes the art: By spoonfuls, add the soft butter, whisking constantly to incorporate each addition. The emulsion begins to form and you may add the butter in slightly larger amounts, always whisking until fully absorbed. Continue incorporating butter until the sauce has thickened into a consistently light texture. Taste and adjust the seasoning, adding droplets of lemon juice if needed. Taste it, add some more lemon (the sauce should be distinctly lemony), and add a pinch of cayenne. C' est ça!
Monday, April 24, 2017
Important guidelines for your final draft submission (HONORS classes) pay attention!!!
1- You're supposed to hand the final draft on the day of the final.
2- The draft must be stapled, no binders, no cover page.
3- At the top left the draft:
PHI 2010 HONORS
John Doe (your name)
MWF 10am class
4- Your draft should be written in Times New Roman point 12,
paginated on the top, right hand side.
5- Title in bold (centered).
6- Your draft must be double spaced, with a minimum of 1,200 words.
7- MLS style of citations, (all same font, same size, including online sources).
8- Please, properly spell check your drafts.
All of these details are worth points!!
Sunday, April 23, 2017
draft's second revision
* begin each paragraph with "so-and-so" ADVOCATES or "so-and-so" CRITICS.
* internal coherence: check paragraphs 3, 5 for arguments 1& 2 of your thesis and paragraphs 4, 6 for arguments 1 and 2 of the counter. there must be a correspondence between these paragraphs. example, if you find anything in paragraph 3 or 5 that doesn't correspond to your first or second points of your thesis YOU HAVE A PROBLEM OF COHERENCE. please, pay attention to this point!
* COPY AND PASTE PROBLEMS (70% for argument, 30% for quote). here if the paragraph looks too good then it's not good. Write down C/P (copy and paste), "I need your voice." Very likely these paragraphs are copied-and-pasted. Just call it! or I'll call it!
AT LEAST 4 SOURCES IN BIBLIOGRAPHY. EVERY FACTOID IN THE DRAFT PROPERLY OUTSOURCED.
KANT'S SECOND FORMULATION APPLIED TO ONESELF
TREAT PEOPLE AS ENDS IN THEMSELVES, NEVER AS A MEANS TO AN END
1. "Persons" means a specific club of persons. Humans, in this case, we have:
2- ENDS in THEMSELVES ARE NON-NEGOTIABLE.
3- MERELY, as... turning people into INSTRUMENTS, means to further ENDS
ANALYSIS OF RESPECT = DIGNITY
How does Kant define respect? SELF-WORTH. DIGNITY (ALL PRIMARY PROPERTIES OF SELF)
ALSO, SYMMETRY AND SELF-SYMMETRY.
arguments in favor of the existence of God
1. the scholastic philosophers of the middle ages used deductive arguments to prove the existence of God, but they didn't do it in the way we do it today. in the middle ages most -if not ALL- people believed in the existence of God. the arguments were supposed to add reasons to your (already existing) beliefs. it was a didactic exercise in reasoning more than a response to a counterargument.
2. I must remind you that in a deductive argument you don't need to speak of existence SOLELY as an empirical property. here's a definition of existence.
DEF: a, b, c... exist if they exist and have properties f-ness, g-ness, and h-ness independent of anyone’s beliefs, linguistic practices, conceptual schemes, and so on.
if you want a good example of something that exists independently of our beliefs about it look no further than math itself. so, for instance:
every natural number greater than 1 is either a prime itself or can be factorized as a product of primes.is independent of our beliefs.
__________
Aquinas cosmological argument (cause/effect)
1- There are things that are caused by other things.Analysis: 2- goes back to Parmenides' point "nothing comes from nothing", meaning that a cause needs a previous cause, which is true. 3- now Aquinas discards infinite regress, He's appealing to a principle in physics, which is complex enough. His conclusion is axiomatic, the uncaused cause is GOD.
2- Nothing can be the cause of itself.
3- There cannot be an infinite regress of objects causing other objects to exist.
Therefore, there must be an uncaused first cause, called God.
Counter from Hume: For Hume there is no problem of imagining an infinite series of cause/effect. In other words, there is no beginning to the universe. Brian Greene inflation: Hume's idea brings us to the idea of 9 types of INFLATION, defended by physicist Brian Greene from Columbia University, in this scenario, there are different pockets in which inflation fields collapse and form new universes. In other words, universes come and go creating a permanent self-contained inflation.
Anselm's Ontological argument (aprioristic)1- God is by definition the greatest being possible.
2- Suppose that most perfect being exists only in the mind.
3- Let's agree that a being that exists in the mind and in reality is greater than a being that exists only in the mind.
4- If God exists only in the mind, we can imagine something greater than God (the greatest possible being that we established by hypothesis existing in reality).
5- But we cannot imagine something that is greater than God (we can be confident that God exists, because we know that a being that can be conceived and actually exists is greater than a being that merely can be conceived but does not exist.
Therefore, God exists.Analysis: Anselm is appealing to an a priori deductive argument.
1- is true. 2- simply advances a hypothesis of existence only in the mind. 3- remember that SOLELY existing in the mind means that the most perfect may not exist in reality. 4- makes the obvious point that existing in reality is more perfect than not existing. now 5 takes us to a contradiction. The conclusion simply states that a being that can be conceived and actually exists is greater than a being that merely can be conceived but does not exist.Gaunilo's counter to Anselm: click here for Gaunilo's counter to Anselm.
Decartes argument:Counter to Pascal: Pascal's wager has been attacked from theists. In the sense that believing in God for the sake of probabilities is a demoted form of belief. Faith cannot be negotiated in the manner Pascal prescribes it.
1. God by definition possesses all possible perfections.
2. Existence is a perfection.
Therefore: God exists.
Pascal's wager (statistical argument)
1- God is, or God is not.
2- Reason cannot decide between the two alternatives.
3- Let's weigh the gain and the loss in wagering that God is.
4- If you gain, you gain all; if you lose, you lose nothing.
Wager, then, without hesitation that HE IS.
my notes on kantian formalism
We should start with this question: what is the right thing to do?, which Kant considers takes us into ethical territory.
TO UNDERSTAND THIS POINT, WE NEED PERSON PROPERTIES:
REASON,
The human faculty dealing with this Kant calls PRACTICAL REASON.
BREAKING A PROMISE IS WRONG.
This brings up the idea of moral obligation. Kant says,
There are two aspects here: 1. UNIVERSALIZABILITY, 2. REVERSIBILITY
The action must satisfy the two branches simultaneously.
There are two maxims here, the left (universalizability) and the right (reversibility).
"R" Reversibility (is one-to-one), and it requires "a putting in the place of b" the old Golden Rule: "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you."
"U" Universalizability: one imagines oneself as representing the club of "Homo Sapiens," sort of saying: "my action now becomes universally required for all moral agents" (a one-to-all relationship).
Wednesday, April 19, 2017
Notes to Utilitarianism
Keep in mind that utilitarians are all consequentialists: An action is right because of the consequences of the actions.
Utilitarianism is a 100% British moral theory. A side note: Karl Marx loved England's political climate because of utilitarianism. A famous utilitarian in the 19th Century was J. Stuart Mill. In the 20th century, we have Richard M. Hare, and a great advocate for animal rights, Professor Peter Singer.
Note: Utilitarianism wins over egoism as a social theory. Here we have to go to the explicit terms of the theory. One favors the individual, and the other favors the group. If you vote for politicians A & B and you know A is an egoist and B a utilitarian, you'd be smart enough to vote for B.
Utilitarianism seems logical in the case of the trolley mind experiment.
As before, a trolley is hurtling down a track towards five people. You are on a bridge under which it will pass, and you can stop it by putting something very heavy in front of it. As it happens, there is a very fat man next to you – your only way to stop the trolley is to push him over the bridge and onto the track, killing him to save five. Should you proceed?This is more difficult:
A brilliant transplant surgeon has five patients, each in need of a different organ, each of whom will die without that organ. Unfortunately, there are no organs available to perform any of these five transplant operations. A healthy young traveler, just passing through the city the doctor works in, comes in for a routine checkup. In the course of doing the checkup, the doctor discovers that his organs are compatible with all five of his dying patients. Suppose further that if the young man were to disappear, no one would suspect the doctor. Should he let the five patients die or save their lives?
Problems with the calculation of happiness
* HAPPINESS IS DEFINED NOT ONLY IN TERMS OF QUANTITY BUT ALSO OF QUALITY. Example: what gives more happiness, to watch a bad series on
TV or a good film? To spend two hours watching porno or to have a nice
conversation with your girlfriend?
* HOW CAN HAPPINESS BE DISTRIBUTED? Suppose that what makes John happy is not what makes Peter happy. Take it to the social level: What makes Group A happy doesn't make Group B happy. Suppose furthermore that group A is a majority and group B is a minority. A seems to win more happiness because there are many more members of A than members of B.
Two counterarguments against Traditional Utilitarianism (you need to know them).
* McCloskey Utilitarian Informant: In a mixed town there's racial strife brought about as a result of a black man raping a white woman. A chief of police decides that a quick arrest of a black person (who is innocent) will stop the riots. He concludes that he's doing the right thing by following the traditional utilitarian calculus. However, the action is wrong since it violates an innocent person's rights.
* Brandt Utilitarian Heir: A family of two brothers their wives and kids and an elderly, rich father, who is paying for a very expensive treatment which would only prolong his life a bit more at the expense of ruining his savings. The older brother decides to kill the father thus increasing the happiness everyone considered. And yet, is this his duty? It doesn't seem so.
* Godwin's Fire Rescue: A very religious man faces a dilemma of whom to save from a certain death in a fire. His best friend is in the opposite room where the Archbishop of Cambray is staying. It seems the right thing to do for a pious man to save the Archbishop, his life would be more valuable than that of his best friend.
Rule Utilitarianism: An action is right if it falls under a rule, which if followed would maximize happiness everyone considered. This is the same as above, but checked by local rules first.
We know there are rules. For instance "do not kill" is a rule. So now, the utilitarian is saying that in the examples above the utilitarian informant is wrong in arresting the black person (the rule in this case is treat "people fairly").
Counterargument to Rule Untilitarianism:
A rule that would allow you to kill somebody whenever doing so would
produce more happiness than unhappiness is not permitted. But a rule
that allowed you to kill somebody whenever it would produce a great deal more happiness would be morally correct.
Monday, April 17, 2017
happiness is a warm gun (with math included)
I'm suggesting to you that happiness is not outside in the world. Happiness is INSIDE. Indeed,
Aristotle and the ancient Stoics talked about keeping an inner balance.
Let's call this balance "happiness."
happiness is a distribution factor "soothing" adversity.
The world is in constant opposition with us. The only way to WIN the world is not by fighting back, that's stupid. Fighting the world means spending your energy for nothing (since the world is supervenient on you). The only way to WIN is to play with the world. Adversity is just a frame of mind. We should arm ourselves with a shield against adversity.
Here's the shield in 3 steps:
1- keep the world at bay (it's called ATARAXIA)
2- do as much good as you can (without loosing yourself in the effort, it's called EUNOIA or benevolence), so the world gives you back what you sow.
3- when necessary be prepared to turn defeat into victory (it's called GRIT).
this is where math comes in,
there's a function suggested by Gauss & Laplace, concerning probability distributions. I'm simplifying the details. The point is that you could see happiness as factor dealing with a distribution of adversity:
to be happy you have to know how to deal with adversity.
yeah, happiness is a warm gun.















